Most 'top loyalty app' lists look the same. This one ranks 7 apps on the criteria that actually matter: price at scale, embedded storefront placement, Shopify POS depth, feature breadth, and setup time. Written by people who build one of them, with full transparency about that bias.
If you've been searching the Shopify App Store for a loyalty app, you've probably noticed something: most "top loyalty app" lists look the same. Smile, Yotpo, LoyaltyLion at the top, a few smaller apps below, no real difference between them on the page. The reviews look similar, the screenshots look similar, the pricing pages all hide the real numbers.
This is an honest ranking of the 7 best Shopify loyalty apps in 2026, written by people who build one of them. We'll be transparent about that bias — Love Loyalty is in this list — and stick to facts you can verify on each product's App Store listing and pricing page.
If by the end you decide a different app is the right fit for your store, that's a fine outcome.
───────────────────────────────────
Five criteria, weighted by what actually matters when a Shopify store launches loyalty:
───────────────────────────────────
Best for: Shopify stores doing $200K to $50M annually who want loyalty embedded everywhere, all-in-one features, and pricing that doesn't get punishing at scale.
Pricing: Free up to 150 orders/mo. Professional $12/mo. Growth $79/mo. Plus $399/mo.
Love Loyalty was built specifically to replace the pop-up widget model. Loyalty surfaces appear inside the cart drawer, the product page, the checkout, the thank-you page, the customer account page, and a dedicated loyalty page — 20+ embedded touchpoints in total, no floating bubble. The result is roughly 2.5x higher loyalty program engagement vs. setups that hide loyalty behind a widget.
Other things worth knowing:
Where it loses: Smaller brand recognition than Smile or Yotpo. EU-based team (global live chat, but support hours skew European).
───────────────────────────────────
Best for: Early-stage stores with very simple needs (pure points + referrals) and no plans to use Shopify POS or paid memberships.
Pricing: Free up to 200 orders/mo. Starter $49/mo. Growth $199/mo. Plus $999/mo.
Smile is the most established loyalty app on Shopify — over 100,000 installs and a strong brand. The product is solid for stores that want a basic program and don't need anything beyond points and referrals. Above 500 orders per month though, the price curve gets steep fast, and the floating widget is still the default presentation.
Where it wins: Brand recognition, US-Canada support, the Shopify App Store ranks it high by install count.
Where it loses: No native paid memberships, no native B2B loyalty, pop-up widget by default, the Growth plan jumps from $49 to $199 quickly.
───────────────────────────────────
Best for: Stores already using Yotpo for reviews and SMS marketing, where bundling loyalty into the same vendor makes sense.
Pricing: Free tier limited. Paid tiers start around $199/mo and scale sharply with orders.
Yotpo Loyalty (formerly Swell) is a strong loyalty product if you're already locked into the Yotpo ecosystem. As a standalone loyalty purchase, it's expensive for the feature set, and the platform was built cross-channel rather than Shopify-native. Many merchants report long onboarding cycles.
Where it wins: Bundles cleanly with Yotpo Reviews and Yotpo SMS, dashboard consolidation.
Where it loses: Pricing scales sharply with order volume, less Shopify-specific than alternatives, complex onboarding.
───────────────────────────────────
Best for: $5M+ Shopify stores with a dedicated CRM operations team and budget for custom integrations.
Pricing: Starts around $199/mo. Enterprise tiers regularly hit $2,000+/mo.
LoyaltyLion is the enterprise pick. The data integrations are deeper than anyone else, the customer success team is robust, and the platform handles complex tier and segmentation logic well. The price reflects all of that.
Where it wins: Enterprise data integrations (Snowflake, BigQuery), dedicated account managers, deep customization.
Where it loses: Overkill and overpriced for stores under $5M annually, setup typically takes weeks, not days.
───────────────────────────────────
Best for: Smaller Shopify stores that prioritize design and Shopify-native UX over feature depth.
Pricing: Free tier. Paid plans start at $49/mo.
Rivo is a newer entrant focused on clean design and Shopify-native integration. The feature set is narrower than the bigger players — no native paid memberships, lighter POS support — but the brand experience is polished.
Where it wins: Design quality, Shopify-native build, smooth UX.
Where it loses: Smaller feature surface, no paid memberships natively, less depth on POS and B2B.
───────────────────────────────────
Best for: Stores that want loyalty bundled with reviews, wishlist, UGC, and referrals in one app.
Pricing: Free tier. Paid plans from $49/mo.
Growave is the bundler. You get acceptable feature depth across loyalty, reviews, wishlist, UGC, and referrals in a single subscription. Trade-off: none of those features is best-in-class.
Where it wins: Single-app consolidation, decent value if you need all five features.
Where it loses: Loyalty depth is shallow vs. dedicated apps, mediocre POS support.
───────────────────────────────────
Best for: Very small Shopify stores running a points program for the first time.
Pricing: Free tier covers most basic needs. Paid plans from $25/mo.
BON is the budget pick. The free plan is genuinely usable for small stores, and the product is simple to set up. The feature depth ends quickly though — no paid memberships, limited POS, no B2B.
Where it wins: Generous free plan, simple setup.
Where it loses: Limited features beyond points and basic VIP tiers, smaller install base.
───────────────────────────────────
App
Best for
Free plan
Mid-tier
POS native
Paid memberships
Love Loyalty
$200K-$50M Shopify stores
Up to 150 orders
$79/mo
Every plan
Yes
Smile.io
Early-stage simple programs
Up to 200 orders
$199/mo
Higher tiers
No
Yotpo
Existing Yotpo customers
Limited
$199+/mo
Higher tiers
Limited
LoyaltyLion
Enterprise $5M+
Trial only
$199+/mo
Yes
Yes
Rivo
Design-led smaller stores
Yes
$49/mo
Limited
No
Growave
Bundle seekers
Yes
$49/mo
Limited
No
BON
Very small stores
Generous
$25/mo
No
No
───────────────────────────────────
Three honest questions to ask yourself before installing anything:
1. What's your monthly order volume?
Under 200 orders/mo: any free plan works, pick the app whose UX you prefer. Smile or BON are fine for "I just need a basic points program".
200-2,000 orders/mo: this is where pricing starts to matter. Love Loyalty at $79/mo vs Smile at $199/mo is a real $1,440/year decision.
2,000+ orders/mo: you need features (paid memberships, B2B, deeper POS) and pricing that doesn't scale punitively. Love Loyalty or LoyaltyLion.
2. Do you sell in-store via Shopify POS?
If yes, your loyalty app needs to work natively at the register. Love Loyalty includes the native POS extension on every plan. Smile and LoyaltyLion put their best POS support behind higher pricing tiers.
3. Will you run paid memberships?
A growing share of DTC brands layer paid memberships on top of free points programs. Love Loyalty and LoyaltyLion ship this natively. Smile, Rivo, Growave, and BON do not.
───────────────────────────────────
Love Loyalty's Free plan supports up to 150 orders per month and includes points, referrals, basic VIP tiers, native Shopify POS, and Apple/Google Wallet passes. BON Loyalty also has a generous free tier. Smile's free plan covers up to 200 orders but locks paid memberships and B2B loyalty behind much higher tiers.
Love Loyalty includes a native Shopify POS extension on every plan, including Free, with earn/redeem at the register and automatic VIP discounts. Smile and LoyaltyLion both technically support Shopify POS but require higher-priced plans for full functionality.
Smile.io, Love Loyalty, and Rivo all currently hold the Built for Shopify badge. The badge signals that the app meets Shopify's highest standards for performance, design, and integration.
At equivalent feature scope (VIP tiers, paid memberships, deeper POS), Love Loyalty is consistently 4 to 10 times cheaper than Smile.io, Yotpo, or LoyaltyLion. The Growth plan at $79/mo replaces what Smile charges $199/mo for and what LoyaltyLion charges $500+/mo for.
About 15 minutes with Love Loyalty's AI loyalty program builder. Smile, Yotpo, and LoyaltyLion typically take 1-3 hours for self-setup and several days if you want assisted onboarding.
If you genuinely need loyalty plus reviews plus wishlist plus UGC plus referrals in one subscription, Growave is fine. If loyalty is your primary need, a dedicated app gives you significantly more depth.
───────────────────────────────────
For most Shopify stores in 2026, the honest answer to "what's the best loyalty app?" depends on stage and stack:
If you want to start with the free plan and see how it feels in your storefront — the install takes about 5 minutes:
Ready to give your customers a loyalty program they'll actually use?
We're happy to set up the app for you so you can get started in 15 minutes.
[Book a 15-minute call](/pricing) · [Install Love Loyalty free from the Shopify App Store](https://apps.shopify.com/loyalty-program-2)
5.0 ★ across 320+ reviews · Built for Shopify · 1,500+ brands
.png)
